Biomass Resources Potentials in Bangladesh :
Depletion of Tropical Forests with Particular Reference to Bangladesh Forest depletion has become a severe phenomenon in all over the world and
developing countries in particular in recent times. An attempt was taken to
estimate the world's forest resources by the Food and Agricultural Organisations
of United Nations in 1990. The global assessment included 179 countries with a
total land area of 12900 million ha. Forests constituted slightly over 3400
million ha or 27% of the land area. The total growing stock was 384000 million m3
. Forests of the developed regions represented by about 42% of the total global
forest area and 43% of total growing stock. The same figures for the developing
region were 58% and 57% respectively. The loss of forest area during 1980-90 was
estimated to 163 million ha, of which 154 million ha was in the tropics only.
Mainly as a result of population growth and shrinking forest area in the
developing regions, per capita forest area fell globally from an average of
nearly 1.2 ha in the 1960 to 0.6 ha in 1990 and it is projected to be less than
0.2 ha by 2020. Deforestation and forest degradation trends are expected to
continue and even to worsen, unless policies are set and implemented to conserve
the world's forest resources. The problems of local wood shortages, land
degradation, global warming, and biodiversity loss were expected to be
exacerbated (FAO, 1995a). Bangladesh is the one of the most densely populated country in the tropics.
Bangladesh lies between 20o 34¢ and 26o 38¢ north
latitude and between 88o 01¢ and 92o 41¢ east longitude.
Agriculture is the major land use of the country. The country has got 13.02
million ha area with 120 million people. The total forest area of Bangladesh is
about 2.47 million ha, which nearly accounts for 18% of its total land area,
which is 0.15% of the world's total tropical forests. There are a lot of controversial estimates among the organisations on the
scale of forest area and the deforestation rate in the country. In Bangladesh,
though forest land is 18-19% of the total land area, 10-12% are declared as
forest and tree cover is only 5-7% according to a present estimate. Other
estimate says that the total natural forest cover 769000 ha which is 5.9% of
total land area and the area of plantations is 335000 ha which is 2.5% of the
total land area (FAO, 1993). The Ganges, the Jamuna and the Meghna river system with their tributaries,
one of the largest in the world (watershed area is about 1090000 sq. km) brings
2.4 billion tonnes of silt per year and the coastal land of Bangladesh is
growing towards the Bay of Bengal. The rate of new accretion was 35 sq. km/year
in 1989. These lands are more or less stable and suitable for artificial
mangrove afforestation. Realising the above facts the government Forest
Department (FD) started a massive afforestation programme since 1965 and up to
June, 1985 an amount of 37000 ha coastal land had been planted. The total area
of present coastal plantation may be about 89000 ha. The FD estimated area is
probably more but contradicts with the survey of Space Research and Remote
Sensing Organisation (SPARRSO) in Bangladesh. The available area for future
plantation in the coastal region in Bangladesh may be about 100000 ha. There are 57000 wood industry production units with 0.21 million employees.
Primary industries include sawmilling and pulp and paper, plywood/veneer, match
and panelboard. Secondary industries are furniture, seasoning, treatment and
preservation. The estimated demand for saw logs in the country in 1991 was 4.3
million m3 compared to a sustainable local supply of 1.3 million m3
. The 1993 total wood supply is 6.2 million m3 against a demand of
8.34 million. Sixty-five percent of forest products are consumed as fuelwood.
Unrecorded production, illicit felling and smuggling accounts for 20% of
supplies (GOB, 1993). Including all aspects, estimated total forestry employment
today is 0.8 million persons. However, considering its seasonal nature, possibly
up to 1.5 million people benefit from forestry related work directly. Forestry
sector contributes to about 3% of total GDP in Bangladesh. There are intangible
benefits, which are not considered in financial terms. Forest lands account for almost 18% of the nation's land area according to
FD. Just over 5% of forest land is protected. Bangladesh's natural forests are
controlled by the government Forest Department and fall broadly under three main
classes: hill forests, inland deciduous Sal forests, and the Sundarbans mangrove
forests. Inventories show an overall depletion in forest stocks in all the major
forests. About half of the land area controlled by the FD lacks tree cover. The
average annual destruction of forest land in the country was 8000 ha in 1980 and
subsequently it increased to 38000 ha in 1981-90 according to FAO (1993). But
probably the rate of destruction of forest is more severe than the official
statistics. It is very difficult to estimate the real picture indeed. Deforestation affects one eighth of the country's land areas. The major
direct cause of deforestation is the land clearances for agriculture,
principally through shifting cultivation in the hill forests. Other causes
include land use changes, forest land encroachments, grazing, fire, uncontrolled
and waste full commercial logging, illegal felling, and fuel wood collection
(GOB, 1993). Bangladesh's low land area to man ratios illustrate the intensive
competition for the very limited land resources. Deforestation and degradation
of the forest resource is the direct result, both are increasing as the
population expands. While existing forest cover is lost on a large scale, there
are very small gains by afforestation of denuded areas and newly accreted land.
Local wood supply cannot keep up with the demand for raw materials resulting in
shortages and increased use of imports. Biomass fuels are predominantly used in
household cooking. Outdated inefficient technology is evident in forest resource
harvesting and manufacturing, resulting in unnecessary wastage. This type of forest is tropical moist evergreen and semi-evergreen in nature
(greater Chittagong, CHT and Sylhet region) which comprise roughly 45% of the
country's total forest. The main species are natural Dipterocarps and its
associates including also a portion of plantation species. The main causes of
depletion of hill forest is due to shifting cultivation and over-exploitation.
Clear felling followed by artificial regeneration system has been practised in
the hill forest for long period. Ironically the fact is that these areas were
not replanted with proper management and silvicultural practices. The
establishment of the plantation is also really difficult in the clear felled
areas due many other causes, among which, extreme human interference,
encroachment of the land for agricultural conversion and habitation and the
grazing are the main problems. Tribal people inhabit in some part of the hill
forests, who usually practice the shifting cultivation. The small boundary of
Bangladesh with Myanmar is in this hill forest area. The Rohynga refugees of
about 1 million were forced to take shelter in the hill forests area in 1990 due
to the military operation in that part of Myanmar adjacent to Bangladesh. The
United Nations High Commission for Refugees are working till now to repatriate
them again in Myanmar. A quarter of them has already returned. In the meantime
of the slow negotiation process a great havoc of destruction of the large part
of the forest has occurred. This has put oil in the fire of destruction which
was continuing previously by the local illegal timber traders. The illicit
felling is done by the poor villagers, who usually work for the illegal traders,
local influential leaders and forest land encroachers. The Sal forests comprise an area of 0.12 million ha. This belongs under the
tropical moist deciduous forest class (greater Dhaka, Mymenshing, Tangail,
Rangpur and Dinjapur region) which constitutes of about 10% of the total forest.
The great destruction occurred during the liberation war of Bangladesh in 1970
in the whole country and in the Sal forests as well. The natural Sal forests was
previously managed under clear felling followed by coppice regeneration.
Government banned the felling realising the fact that the forest had degraded
due to excessive felling and coppicing. But the law was unable to protect this
natural deciduous forest. This central and northern part of the country is most
densely populated. The main cause of depletion of this forest was due to the
land clearance for agriculture and forest land encroachment. The almost half of
the total Sal forest has been already depleted. The remaining patches are in
poor condition, degraded and in the process of depletion. Some measures by the
government and also non-governmental organisations were taken to involve the
farmer in the forestry i.e., agroforestry and community woodlot plantations.
This was in vein and ineffective to halt the deforestation process and
encroachment in spite of very little success. The negligence and corruption of
the government forest department staffs and the extended support of the local
political leaders to the encroachers are also liable. Recently, another problem
has been found that the farmers who participated in the community forestry
programs are not getting their share from the harvesting of the crop. Initially
all shareholders agreed to the program that the profit will be distributed to
them according to some predetermined ratio. However, due to lack of proper
management and prompt response from the government FD when the plantations have
reached to the harvesting age for the first rotation, the farmers stoped looking
after the plantations. Mature trees are now being felled and taken away by the
illicit loggers taking this opportunity of inactivity of farmers. Once the
trusts of the farmers are lost, then it will be very difficult to regain for
government FD and to implement this type of participatory approach of forestry
practice in future. Encroachment and illicit removal of timber and firewood from the forests are
the major forest conservation problems in the area. The Sal forests are under
constant human pressure from all sides as there were no boundary of the forest.
The forests are in patches, intermingled with private agricultural lands and
habitation encircling that small blocks of forest. The areas under encroachments
estimated about 0.036 million ha and the number of encroachers are about 100000.
The chief reasons of encroachments are: legal lacunae due to past tenurial
history of the lands, and intricate nature of the boundary of the forest land
and cultivable lands, and failure to complete the forest settlement operations
initiated in the 1950's. The main reason of illicit removal of timber are: wide
gap between the demand and supply of wood and its consequent high prices
(illicit removal of even a head-load of firewood turns out to be more paying
than a day's wage of rural labourer, removal of timber and poles is even more
paying); limited year round employment in rural areas resulting in compelling
dependence on collection of wood from the forests for subsistence; existence of
organised groups of illicit mongers who professionally indulge in illicit
cutting and removal of valuable trees of the forests (Chowdhury, 1994). Most of the Sal forests are now severely degraded and poorly stocked. Some
three decades ago, more than 60 percent of these forests were fairly densely
wooded. But today, the forest has been reduced both in extent and tree density
as well as stand quality. These are, in fact, the worst hit of all the forests
in the country. FAO estimated that about 36 percent of the forest cover existed
in 1985; more recent estimates (1990) suggest that only about 10 percent of the
forest cover remains. Despite a moratorium imposed in 1972 on extraction of wood
from Sal forests, illicit felling have continued unabated. The Sundarbans Reserve Forests composed of 0.58 million ha of area (greater
Khulna and Bagerhat region) of which 0.41 million ha is mangrove forests and
0.17 million ha is open water areas in rivers, channels and creaks. The
Sundarbans is the largest single tract mangrove formation in the world. The main
species is Sundri (Heritiera spp) and other associated mangroves mainly species
belongs to Rhizophorace family (Sonneratia spp., Excoecaria spp., Xylocarpus spp.,
Ceriops spp. etc.). The forest is fully controlled and managed by the Government
Forest Department. This is legally declared as a Reserve Forest so there is no
human habitation and locality inside the forest except some in the periphery.
The Sundarbans constitute about 45 percent of the natural productive forests and
provide livelihood for at least 0.5 million people mainly wood cutters,
fisherman, honey collectors and Nypa palm leaf (fronds) locally known as Golpata
collectors, Phoenix paludosa (hental) collectors, shell collectors and
fishermen. Beside forest resources, the Sundarbans forest is extremely important
for fish production, wildlife conservation, recreation and serves as a
protective barrier against coastal erosion, cyclones, storms and tidal surges.
The mangrove forests and mudflats of the Sundarbans provide the vital breeding
and nursery grounds for a large proportion of the fin fish, crustaceans and
molluscs. The significant depletion of the growing stock, notably of Heritiera (Sundri)
and Excoecaria (Gewa) which appears to have been reduced by 40% and 45%
respectively between 1959 and 1983. The incidence of top dying of Heritiera spp
which seems to be increasing with rapid ecological changes rendering the site
unsuitable for the species. The lack of experienced and trained staff,
inadequate data base, accessibility are also the main problems to manage the
forest properly. The main reasons of the depletion of this forest are due to the corruption
and negligence of the some Forest Department staffs, illegal traders, local
influential leaders, some government officials concerned, section of police-man,
section of local journalists etc. Often the local poor people are used to
destroy the forests taking tolls (many times higher than government rate) from
them illegally. Other reasons are improper and poor management, over
exploitation and also ecological reasons to some extent. The construction of the
Farraka barrage over the upstream of the Ganges by India in West Bengal, reduced
the water flow significantly during dry season which increased the salt
intrusion from the sea water and disturbed/changed/altered/modified the
ecosystem. The causes of the 40% top-dying of the main species Sundri (Heretiera
spp) is still partially known. The depletion of this mangrove forest should be
stopped immediately due to its ecological significance. The conscious world
should come forward to stop the further depletion of the mangroves in the Indian
Subcontinent and to support the programme for its proper conservation. Recently,
the Sundarbans mangrove forests has been declared as a world heritage site by
the UNESCO. This would help and push the Government of Bangladesh to take
necessary steps to protect and reserve this unique dynamic but fragile and
complex ecosystem. The major consequences of deforestation, at present Bangladesh is facing,
seriously hamper the economy. The effects of uncontrolled logging is most
destructive in the hilly areas. Because of that reason, land slides and soil
erosion have increased significantly. Soil degradation in the plain lands due to
the nutrient deficiency is common. Previous natural nutrient cycling from the
forest to the plain arable lands has been destroyed by clearing the forest and
afterwards using huge overdose of chemical fertilisers and uncontrolled use of
the hazardous toxic pesticides. The dose of the chemical fertilizer application
is increasing every year and at the end resulting in infertile, barren soil.
Land degradation is accelerated by this process. The desertification was
initiated a decade ago in the northern part of the country. A recent report
shows that in the greater Pabna district 2 lakhs acres of land may be degraded
or baren in next 20 years out of total arable land 9.5 lakh acres mainly for the
erosions due to lack of vegetation or tree cover. There are many situations in
other areas as well. The abnormal variation in diurnal temperature and seasonal
weather than the past records indicate to be alarmed. The devastation after the
cyclones and storms in exposed areas to the bay near the coastal lines is now
more severe than the past. The situation is becoming worse as the time passes. In fact, there is a lot of scopes of forestry in Bangladesh. A comprehensive
planning is required to utilise the Unclassed State Forest (USF) land (which is
virtually barren and unproductive), marginal and waste land, homesteads,
roadside lands and railway side, embankments, pond banks, canal and river banks,
institutional premises etc. These lands can be planted with multipurpose tree
species, which may be the significant alternative sources of forest produce and
timbers. That can help to reduce the pressure on the natural forests. Despite
the shortages of skilled forestry personnel, the Green-Belt project by the FD to
restore the coastal lands are promising approach. Forestry graduates from
universities of the country can be appointed to implement this type of program
effectively. The major causes are more or less the similar for the depletion of all the
forest types. In some cases, all these causes are affecting and operating
simultaneously making the situation worse. Without the firm commitment of the
government to stop the forest depletion, probably no change will occur. In
general, motivation, awareness creation among the general public, updating and
enforcement of laws, employing trained, honest and efficient manpower equipped
with forestry knowledge may be some remedial measures. Public and private plantation programmes should be undertaken in the barren
hilly areas and clear felled areas immediately. The most successful story of FD
may be demonstrated like the Betagi Community Forestry model farm as in the hill
forest areas of Chittagong. Landless labourers, farmers, encroachers, illicit
loggers were selected and given about 2 hactares of land to each on lease basis.
They were given also the loan initially for raising the tree plantations.
Periodic repayment of loan was ensured. The income of the farmer had increased
from US$70 to US$1600 per year after seven years of the practice, which has been
shown in several studies. In similar fashion, the hill forest may be recovered
again by selecting the individuals based on some well accepted criteria i.e.,
poverty, gender, regular loan repayment etc. Segments of the poor, destitute
women, landless labourers, small co-operatives, medium entrepreneurs may be the
target client groups. Conservation is the only alternative measure remained for the rapidly
dwindling small area of the Sal forest. Enforcement of the laws, forestry
extension in the adjacent localities, motivation and campaign can stop further
depletion of the forest. For the mangrove forests very specific policy is required by the government.
Enough control of the FD over the Sundarbans is still strong. This may be used
for its proper management and conservation. Immediate steps should be taken to
stop the over-exploitation of resources before complete deterioration of the
administrative control of FD over the Sundarbans. Forests are particularly important in the context of present environmental
degradation and ecological purposes. The location of Bangladesh has made it
prone to natural calamities like flood, draught, storms, cyclones and tidal
upsurge. Though there is a controversy but according to the forecast of
scientific community, the country will probably be the severely affected one by
the green house effect, global warming and sea-level rise. Bangladesh needs
world support to halt further deforestation and degradation of its small amount
but very important valuable natural forests. There are very few alternatives to
protect the environment except the conservation of forests and extension of
forestry. The international bodies should formulate adequate plans before
depletion of the all forests to conserve the forests, tropical forests in
particular, around the whole world. BBS (1993) Statistical Pocketbook of Bangladesh. Bangladesh Bureau of
Statistics, Ministry of Planning, Dhaka. 363p. Chowdhury, R.A. (1994). History and importance of Sal forests and current
management status. In: Agroforestry for the degraded Sal forest. eds. Chowdhury,
R.A., Bhuiyan, A.A., Amin, S.M., Haque, A.K.M., Bose S.K. and M.I.M. Fattah.
Procedings of the national workshop held at the Bangladesh Agricultural Research
Council, Dhaka on Nov 26 to Dec 01, 1994. BARC, FD and Asia Pacific Agroforestry
Network, 09-25pp. FAO (1993) Forest resources assessment 1990: Tropical countries. FAO Forestry
Paper 112, Rome. 102p. FAO (1995a) Forest resources assessment 1990: Global Synthesis. FAO Forestry
Paper 124, Rome. 44p. FAO (1995) Forest resources assessment 1990: Tropical forest plantation
resources. FAO Forestry Paper 128, Rome. 81p. GOB, (1993) Forestry Master Plan: Executive Summary. ADB, UNDP/FAO BGD/88/025,
Forest Department, Government of Bangladesh, Dhaka. 31p. Haque, M.N. (1995). Raising Plantations on Barren Hills. The Bangladesh
Observer, Dhaka. Copyright © 1998 Global Amitech
By Nawshadul Haque, mnhaque@hotmail.com
The writer is currently a postgraduate research student at the University of
Sydney, Australia and also a member of the academic staff in the Forestry &
Wood Technology Discipline, Khulna University.
Some facts and conditions of the forestry sector in Bangladesh
Scale and causes of deforestation in Bangladesh
Hill Forests
The Sal (Shorea spp) Forests
The Sundarbans Mangrove forests
Consequences of forest destruction in Bangladesh
Remedies
Conclusions
REFERENCES
Environmental Philosophy in the Context of
Bangladesh
Md. Khalequzzaman, Assistant Professor of Geology, Georgia
Southwestern State University, Americus, GA 31709, USA. URL:
http://vulcan.gsw.peachnet.edu/khaleq
Bangladesh is facing a tremendous challenge as it stands at the
doorstep of the 21st century. The country's economy is in disarray;
the political instability has become a part of everyday life; the
college campuses have turned into battle grounds; the security of
ordinary citizens is threatened; the natural calamities are rampant;
and the quality of water and air has become unacceptable by world's
standard. Most of these problems have existed in Bangladesh in the
past. However, there is no sign of improvement in the sight, and the
degree of deterioration has reached an alarming proportion. Many
would argue that achieving a prosperous economy and political
stability should be the top two priorities for Bangladesh in order
to provide a decent life for its citizens. Other issues of import
would be the improvement of law and order, education, and the state
of the environment. While all of the issues mentioned above are
important and need to be addressed, some are more important than the
others, because thy are contributing to a crisis situation and are
posing a threat to our survival. The people of Bangladesh need to
set their priorities straight and act upon them immediately.
Setting our priorities straight:
If a gallop poll were conducted among ordinary citizens of
Bangladesh to identify the top priority issues for the 21st century,
it would probably be unlikely that the environment would top the
list. This is to be expected, given the degree of environmental
awareness and the average level of education on environmental that
is available to people through schools and other institutions. I
would, however, argue that in Bangladesh, the improvement of the
state of the environment is a pre-requisite for prosperous economic
development. Only a balance between the environment stewardship and
economic development can guarantee a sustainable future and the well
being of the country in the 21st century.
Environmental stewardship vs. economic development:
The environment is comprised of physical (air, water, soil, mineral
resources, light, and temperature) and biological (plants and
animals) realms. The term "ecology" encompasses a complex
interaction and the delicate ecosystems within which humans exist.
Our dependence on the environment has both a short-term component
and a long-term component. On one hand, since we breathe air, every
minute of our life literally depends on the environment. On the
other hand, the role that other components (such as, mineral
resources, temperature, plants, etc.) of the environment play is not
always very obvious within the timeframe of the human life span.
Quite often the long-term consequences of particular human
activities are overlooked in the interests of short-term gain.
Mineral resources extracted from the earth's crust are the basis for
civilization. Rocks and minerals are the raw materials for most of
the industrial products that we use everyday (oil, gas, coal,
construction materials, fertilizers, metals, rare earth elements,
and radioactive elements are just a few to name). In other words,
most of the products that we use to maintain the standard of living
and comfort come from the environment. Therefore, economic
development is just another term for exploitation of the
environment. Unfortunately, most environmental components have a
finite amount (i.e. non-renewable within a human life span),
non-uniform distribution, and limited carrying capacity. It is for
this reason that we need to understand the dynamism and the
fundamental principles that govern the environment.
A better understanding of the fundamental principles and the
underlying philosophy that govern the balance between components of
the Earth's ecosystem can help us achieve economic development while
safeguarding the environment. These philosophical concepts help us
better comprehend the way our planet works, as well as will help us
evaluate the extent and limitation of earth resources that are
needed to attain a sustainable future. In the following few
paragraphs those principles will be explored in the context of
Bangladesh.
Everything affects everything else:
The environment is a part of the "earth system", which has four
interrelated components, namely, the lithospehre (the earth's outer
layer), atmosphere, hydrosphere (surface and groundwater), and
ecosphere (plants and animals realm). The interrelationship of
various components can be demonstrated with the example of flooding
in Bangladesh. Flooding is a natural phenomenon, which is a part of
the hydrologic cycle (hydrosphere). Human activity (in the
ecosphere), such as deforestation or soil erosion due to tillage,
can reduce the water carrying capacity of rivers, causing more
floods. Also, increased amounts of greenhouse gases in the
atmosphere will result in increased temperatures, causing more
evaporation, precipitation and floods. Volcanic eruptions (in
lithosphere) can melt snow (in hydrosphere) in the mountains,
causing more floods. The above examples demonstrate how all
components of the earth system are interrelated. Many such examples
can be drawn upon to elaborate on this point.
Humans as agents of environmental degradation:
The earth is a dynamic planet that has maintained a delicate balance
through time immemorial. Any external stress imposed upon the
Earth's ecosystem can results in an imbalance among its components,
much like a motor engine that would malfunction due to improper
handling or mismanagement of its components. Humans are part of the
ecosphere, but depend on all the other components for their
survival. Although the human species appeared on Earth only recently
on a geologic time scale compared with the age of the earth, humans
have already proven to be a major denominator in many spheres of the
environment. Humans have accelerated natural changes in the
environment at a rate faster than ever before. During the last few
decades the earth ecosystem has manifested many signs of unbearable
imbalance in its environmental components. Examples of such signs of
imbalance, as demonstrated by nature's fury, would include the
increased rates of: (a) recent major flooding in Bangladesh (in
1988, 1993, and 1998) and elsewhere; (b) depletion of the ozone
layer; (c) global warming due to an increase in greenhouse gases;
(d) sea-level rise and coastal erosion (Bangladesh will be the most
affected country should the sea-level continues to rise in the
future); (e) soil erosion and desertification (northwestern region
in Bangladesh is experiencing desertification); (f) cyclones
(Bangladesh was hit by 7 of the 10 most devastating cyclones in the
world during the last 100 years) ; (g) El Nino and La Nina; (g)
tornadoes (more than 100 severe tornadoes hit Bangladesh during the
last 100 years) ; (h) air pollution (quality of air in Dhaka is the
worst among the major cities in the world) ; and (i) decline in
bio-diversity (along with other rare species, the number of the
Royal Bengal tiger in the Sundarbans is in decline).
The carrying capacity of the earth is limited:
Exponential growth of population is the root cause of most
environmental degradation. The world's population has tripled during
the 20th century; life expectancy has almost doubled during this
time. The world economy, fuel consumption, industrial activities,
and energy consumption have increased by as much as 20, 30, 50, and
80 times, respectively during the last hundred years. This increase
in population has already exerted a tremendous stress on the Earth's
ecosystem, depleting many of the earth's non-renewable resources
(e.g. at the present rate of consumption, the earth's oil/gas
reserve will last for 25 more years); and causing environmental
degradation as mentioned above. The size of the World economy will
have to increase by five times to support the increasing population
at the present standard of living. The resources and land needed for
such economic growth are just not there. The rate of increase in
population in Bangladesh is even higher than that of the world's
average. The carrying capacity of Bangladesh is well above the
normal average. The density of population in Bangladesh is 50 times
higher than in the United States. It is a scary scenario. The rate
of population growth in Bangladesh will have to decline
substantially for us to be able to strike an environmental balance
while still maintaining the kind of decent life that any human being
deserves.
Sustainability is not enough, prosperity is needed:
Sustainable development calls for maintaining the present standard
of living while safeguarding the environment. However, simply
maintaining the current standard of living should not or cannot be
the ultimate goal for our future generations, for it will mean "no
progress." Humans have always striven to improve their standard of
living compared to that of their predecessors. Doing better than
what was possible in the past is the driving force behind progress.
What we need, therefore, is not sustainability, but potential for
prosperity. This should translate into a prudent use of the earth's
resources, as well as an improvement in the quality of the
environment. Discovery of new resources, energy sources, and
innovation in the use of alternative resources can help us achieve
this goal. Bangladesh should develop nuclear energy and solar energy
to produce electricity, and to meet other energy needs of the
country.
Electrification is the foundation for economic prosperity:
Following the October Revolution, V.I. Lenin defined socialism as
"the electrification of the whole country and the transfer of power
to the Soviets (people's representatives)." This goes to show how
important the electrification was for over all development of a
country more than 80 years ago. The need for electrification of
Bangladesh remains just as important even today. I think everyone
will agree that a drastic improvement of the power sector is an
absolute prerequisite for over all development of Bangladesh.
To meet the growing demand of electricity in the domestic and
industrial sectors, Bangladesh will have to come up with a plan for
massive production of power. Because of low terrain and high
population density, the prospect of developing hydroelectric power
is not environmentally feasible. The oil and gas reserve of the
world will eventually diminish (maybe within next two or three
decades). Other means of alternative energy sources include solar
power, wind power, tidal power, and nuclear power. Generation of
electricity using wind requires high wind speed and available open
space. Valleys within mountains can funnel winds at high speed, and
are suitable locations for windmills. Parts of Chittagong and Hill
Tracts might be feasible for generation of electricity using wind
power. Generation of electricity using tidal power is very similar
to hydroelectric power. Tidal channels are dammed of and tidal water
is forced to pass through a narrow gate to which a turbine is
connected. The direction of the turbine can be changed to allow both
incoming flood tide and outgoing ebb tide to work on the turbine.
However, development of tidal power causes problems to navigation
and siltation. Since most tidal channels are used for navigation in
Bangladesh, generation of electricity using tidal power will have to
be limited in isolated channels inside the Sundarbans area. Solar
power uses sun's energy to produce electricity. Solar energy is
plentiful in Bangladesh. Generation of electricity using solar power
is environmentally feasible. Development of solar power should be
top priority for Bangladesh in the 21st century. However, most of
these alternative sources of energy are still more costly compared
to the energy produced by conventional methods. To meet the
increasing demand of energy, Bangladesh should also consider
developing nuclear power as the sources of future energy.
To meet the world's energy demand in the future, further research
and development of the nuclear energy will continue throughout the
world. Many countries in Europe heavily rely on nuclear energy. For
example, France uses up to 75% of nuclear energy to meet the
national demand. Germany, UK, USA, and Japan also use a tremendous
amount of energy generated by nuclear reactors. Although nuclear
energy is very efficient, it is relatively costly. There are some
risks involved in safety procedures and disposal of waste materials
generated in nuclear power plants. Occasional accidents can be
dangerous. However, "media overreaction" and "enviroscare" against
nuclear power plants certainly play a major role in mobilizing
public opinion on this issue. Except for Chernobyl disaster, which
was caused by a faulty and outdated technology in the former Soviet
Union, and the Three Mile Island incidence in the USA, there hasn't
been any significant accident associated with nuclear power
generation. Any other sectors have risk associated with accidents.
For example, the Bhopal disaster in 1984 was caused by a chemical
industry (the Union Carbide), and was equally dangerous. In
addition, the problem of radioactive waste disposal remains an
unresolved issue. As far as the radioactive waste disposal is
concerned (in the case of fission reactors), recent studies show
that clay-rich seabeds can be used for disposal of such waste. The
Bengal fan has one of the highest sedimentation rates in the world
and could be a place for such burial (if we have to).
There are different kinds of nuclear reactors. The most efficient
type is the "Breeder Reactor" which are not only efficient, but also
relatively safer. In addition, the nuclear fusion reactors, as
opposed to fission reactors, use heavy deuterium and tritium (a form
of hydrogen) as a source of reaction. Fusion reactors produce water
as by products--not radioactive waste (i.e. absolutely no
environmental risk is associated with them). These fusion reactors
are still in research stage, but significant strides have been made
in development of these reactors. One gram of deuterium-tritium can
generate energy equivalent to burning 45 barrels of oils! In
addition, research is ongoing to develop cold fusion (i.e. at room
temperature). These are all matters of future. We need to adopt a
power generating technology that is economically feasible and
environmentally sound. Bangladesh is not at the leading edge of
technological research. This situation gives us an opportunity to
learn from other people's mistakes. And with the current trend of
globalization of trade and technology transfer it will be easier to
adopt what is efficient and environmentally feasible for Bangladesh.
Clean air, water, and land are human right:
All people have a right to a clean environment. Material wealth,
such as the guarantee of food, employment, subsistence, education,
and health, will not make human life worthwhile without having clean
air, water, and land. To achieve this goal, Bangladesh needs to
implement stricter laws to control solid waste, industrial waste,
medical waste, and sewage sludge disposal. All municipalities need
to have garbage collection services and sanitary landfills or
incinerators to control solid waste disposal. In addition,
implementation of sanitary toilets in all villages should be a
primary requirement to keep both surface and groundwater clean. All
chemical and liquid wastes need to be treated before disposing in
rivers and streams as effluents. Recent incidences of ammonia
contamination of rivers by the Ghorasal fertilizer factory, trace
metal contamination of soils by the Hazaribagh tannery, arsenic
contamination of millions of tube wells, and lead contamination of
air will become catastrophic in proportion if no mitigation measures
are taken. To reduce environmental degradation caused by
point-sources of pollution (such as, industrial and medical sources
of contamination), the "polluters-pay-policy" (PPP) must be
implemented. Moreover, a better land management practice will be
necessary to control non-point sources of contamination, such as
arsenic, fertilizers, animal waste, detergent, and pesticides. These
higher environmental standards will be costly to Bangladesh in the
short term, but in the long term less costly than contending with
more drastic environmental remediation and the destruction of major
natural resources. These policies are often hard for elected
politicians to sell to a population which is already faced with
financial hardship. Only by educating the public on the need for
immediate action, and on the connection between their survival and
environmental stewardship will this be possible.
Effect of land-use is cumulative:
Gradual degradation of the environment eventually will lead to
catastrophic consequences. For example, every time we build a new
house or a road on the floodplain, we reduce the total run-off area
and groundwater recharge area, which result in an increase in
flooding propensity or in decline in the groundwater table. Filling
up of the lakes (e.g. the recent incidences of encroachment onto and
land-grabbing of Gulshan-Baridhara lakes in Dhaka by the RAJUK) and
rivers by dumping sediments for development reduces the water
carrying capacity of a drainage network, causing water logging and
extended flooding in an area. In order for us to be able to reduce
the flooding propensity in Bangladesh, we have to control building
on the floodplains. Also, deforestation due to development leads to
increased soil erosion, decline in bio-diversity, increase in
flooding, decline in groundwater recharge, and increase in carbon
dioxide (a greenhouse gas) in the atmosphere. In Bangladesh, lateral
spread of development should be contained as much as possible by
implementing more environmentally-sound development, such as cluster
housing and compact township. New development for housing, roads,
shopping malls, or offices will have to be vertical, i.e.
multi-storied. New laws and regulations need to be developed and
strictly enforced to control lateral development onto the
floodplains. Planners and developers must produce an environmental
impact statement (EIS) for their planned land-use activities. The
EIS should include alternative plans, as well as cost/benefit
analysis, which should be reviewed by the general public and
independent experts in the field before implementing.
Most environmental problems are related to Earth processes:
Many environmental problems result from human interactions with
natural processes, extent of which do not conform to political
boundaries. Natural processes cannot be prevented. However, a
comprehensive understanding of these processes can allow us to
effectively plan land-use and thereby mitigate their effect. For
example, flooding in Bangladesh is but a part of the overall
hydrodynamic process that is active in the Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna
watersheds. Bangladesh comprises only 10% of the watershed, and is
located at the receiving end of this basin. Since Bangladesh is a
small part of a bigger hydrodynamic system which consists of several
countries in the region, a mutual understanding and cooperation
among the co-riparian countries will be necessary in order to
formulate any long-term and permanent solution to the flooding
problems. Arsenic contamination of groundwater in Bangladesh is just
another example of a geologic problem that owes its origin to areas
beyond the confines of Bangladesh. Therefore, any clean up measures
for these aquifers could be futile, since Bangladesh is located
down-gradient of the geologic formations that contain water.
However, further research may prove otherwise.
Multiple and aesthetic uses of land:
Because of the scarcity of land, any land-use planning needs to be
designed for more than one purpose, when and if possible. For
example, a lake in a residential area can have multiple purposes:
(a) water sports, (b) fishing, (c) groundwater recharge basin, (d)
recreational park, and (e) flood control reservoir. Another such
example can be the usage of dredged sand from rivers. The dredging
of rivers can: (a) improve water transport, (b) reduce flooding
propensity, (c) supply sand for building and road construction, and
(d) supply sediments to elevate roads and villages, which in turn
can reduce flood damage. In addition, dredged sands that are
enriched with iron hydroxides (e.g. red sand from Barind Tract,
Madhupur Ghar, and Brahmaputra-Tista basin areas) can be used as
liners in ponds to reduce arsenic contamination in surface water.
However, further research will be necessary to study the feasibility
of such usage of red sands.
Recycle-Reuse-Reduce:
This is the most fundamental slogan for environmental awareness.
Most Bangladeshis recycle newspapers, aluminum utensils, and glass
bottles. However, an integrated plan is needed for a nation-wide
recycling plan for everything that is recyclable. Proper
environmental education, workshops, training, and publicity can
increase awareness about reduction in the use of commodities through
the basic concept of recycle-reuse-reduce.
All species have the equal right to survive: according to the "Gaia
Hypothesis" put forward by "Deep Ecologists", all flora and fauna
are nature's creation and have an important role to play in the
intriguing web of life. All species have an equal right to survival.
Human activities have already driven many species from the surface
of the earth. Only a few years ago most jungles in the villages of
Bangladesh were rich in bio-diversity. For instance, hedgehogs,
weasels, lizards, cheetahs, parrots, owls, etc. are now almost
extinct. Stricter environmental laws and better awareness are
necessary to save all species before they are extinct. This is
primarily a result of loss of habitat. This issue will have to be
addressed by setting aside sensitive parcels of land for
bio-diversity and by encouraging the reclamation of certain habitats
through reintroduction of the near-extinct species in those
protected sanctuaries.
The star thrower:
According to an American folk story, two friends were walking on the
beach after a coastal storm that washed thousands of starfish
ashore. As they walked, one of the friends started to pick up
starfish one by one, and started to throw them in the water. The
other friend says, " there are thousands of starfish on the beach,
what difference will it make if you throw just a few in the water?"
His friend picks up another starfish and says, "it will make a
difference for this one" as he throws it in the water. All of us can
be "a star thrower" even in a small way. Everyone can make a
difference. Collectively, we will make a big difference.
Money is not edible:
To summarize, nothing can be said more succinctly than what the
Chief of Mohawk Red Indian Tribe said, "not until the last tree has
fallen, the last river has been poisoned, the last fish has been
caught, will man realize that money isn't edible." We need to act to
preserve the only habitable planet before it is too late.
Can rainwater harvesting be a solution to drinking water problem in
Bangladesh?
Md. Khalequzzaman, Assistant Professor of Geology, Georgia
Southwestern State University, Americus, GA 31709, USA. URL:
http://vulcan.gsw.peachnet.edu/khaleq
There is a common misconception among the villagers in Bangladesh
that rainwater is pure. Since rain form by condensation of
evaporated water (like a distillation process), it seems reasonable
that rainwater would be of good quality. A myth about the purity of
rainwater prevails even among many educated people. In fact, many
quack doctors (I have seen one in our own village when I was a
little boy) in Bangladesh use rainwater to substitute distilled
water used in injections medicine in human body. Now that arsenic
contamination of groundwater in Bangladesh poses serious threat to
health, more and more people are turning to surface water sources.
Rainwater harvesting offers a possible source of drinking water.
Many agencies, including the Water and Sewerage Authority (WASA),
are studying feasibility of rainwater harvesting in Bangladesh. The
most important questions that need to be addressed before harvesting
rainwater are: (1) is rainwater harvesting economically and
technically feasible for rural people? and (2) does rainwater meet
the quality for drinking water?
Amount of rainfall varies both spatially and temporally. While the
maximum amount of average annual rainfall occurs in the northeastern
districts (55 cm) of Sylhet and Moulivibazar, the minimum amount
falls in the western/southwestern districts (15 cm) of Meherpur,
Kushtia, Chuadanga, Chapai Nawabganj, Noagaon, and Rajshahi. Also,
rainfall is mainly restricted during the months of April to
September. Consequently, rainwater harvesting will be relatively
easier during certain months of the year in the certain parts of
Bangladesh. Groundwater contamination by arsenic is more severe in
the western/southwestern districts, where rainwater harvesting would
be more appropriate to solve the polluted drinking water problems. A
1982 study, by the United Nations Environment Program, showed that
with an average rainfall of 72 inches and using 1,100-gallon storage
tanks, enough water could be collected in 12 hours to serve a family
of six for 45 days.
Rainwater harvesting -- in one form or another -- has been in
practice for thousands of years. According to Paul Woods of Texas A
& M University, extensive water harvesting systems in the Negev
Deserts of Israel more than 2,000 years ago have been documented.
Additionally, Roman villas and cities were planned in such a way to
take advantage of rainwater for drinking and air-conditioning.
Cisterns, containers to collect rainwater, were fairly common in the
United States in rural areas until the 1920s. Rainwater harvesting
requires an arrangement to collect, treat, and distribute the
captured rainwater. The quality of rainwater harvesting technology
varies widely depending on the availability of resources available.
For example, a commercial company in Texas deploys sophisticated
technology to collect, treat, and distribute captured rainwater.
Villagers living on the rain-shadow areas of the Andes Mountains use
a long and wide piece of thick cloth raised with long poles like
sails of a boat to collect rainwater. Rooftops in buildings can be
designed to collect rainwater, as is done in Kawranbazar office of
the WASA. However, most buildings in Bangladesh are not designed for
rainwater harvesting. Structural modification of buildings will be
necessary to make them suitable for rainwater harvesting. Such an
investment will be beyond the financial means of most families
living in Bangladesh. In addition, millions of slum dwellers, who
constitute the majority of the city population and who are in dire
need of clean drinking water, will have difficulty to adopt such
techniques to say the least. The situation in the villages is even
worse as it pertains to rainwater harvesting. Although it will be
financially burdensome, most tin-roofed houses can be modified to
capture rainwater by adding a gutter system. However, most villagers
living in houses made out of straws will not likely to have the
means and resources to adopt such rainwater harvesting technique.
Next question is how to keep the rainwater for dry season? Saving
rainwater in vessels for later use will be practically impossible,
for it will require a huge number of such containers. Another
possibility would be to dig ponds to gather rainwater for use during
dry months. However, a series of problems will arise from such
measure. First, there are not enough lands available in various
parts of all villages in Bangladesh. Second, ponds will be subject
to surface run-off that will carry different pollutants from
non-point sources. Possible non-point sources of contamination
include fertilizer, pesticides, chicken and cow manure, dissolved
minerals, sediments, sewage, decaying plants, algae, bacteria,
aerosol fallout, and detergents. The amount of surface run-off can
be reduced by building elevated banks around ponds. Third, water
will be lost to evaporation if the ponds are not completely covered.
Fourth, ponds will be connected to groundwater flow and will be
subject to contamination by dissolved chemicals. Most feasible
option would be conjunctive and seasonal use of rainwater during wet
months, and other sources of surface water and groundwater during
dry months.
Studies of the chemical composition of rainfall have been carried on
for many years starting in late 1880s in the United States and in
Europe. Rainwater collected in various parts of the USA contains (in
milligrams per liter): Fe (0.015) , Ca (0.075-1.41), Mg (0.027-1.2),
Na (0.22-9.4), Ca (0.075-1.41), K (0.072-0.11), HCO3 (4-7), SO4
0.7-7.6), Cl (0.22-17), NO2 (0.02), NO3 (0.02-0.62), and Total
Dissolved Solids 8.2-38), and pH of 4.9 to 6.4. Although most of
these concentrations fall within the safe limit prescribed by the US
Environmental Protection Agency, some exceed safe drinking water
limit.
Rainwater in rural areas - away from atmospheric and industrial
pollution - is fairly clean except for some dissolved gases it may
pick up while traveling through the atmosphere. Some scientists
consider rainwater as the "gold standard" of water. However,
rainwater is not free of pollution. It contains most of the
atmospheric gases in dissolved form in proportion to their
abundance. In addition, rainwater contains sediments, dust,
aerosols, particulates, and anthropogenic gases that result from
industrial discharge, biomass and fossil fuel burning. Gases such as
H2O, SO2, NH3, NO2, N2O, HCl, CO, and CO2 are produced in
substantial amounts by burning of fuels, by metallurgical processes,
and by other anthropogenic activities, and also by biochemical
processes in soil and water. Carbonates, nitrates, and sulfates in
the atmosphere can react with water vapor and form carbonic, nitric,
and sulfuric acids, respectively. These acids washed down with rain
and form acid rain, which is detrimental to ecosystem and water
quality. Since rainwater is not pure water, some precautions will
have to be taken before the water is consumed. Sediments will have
to be removed, and water further purified by using a reverse osmosis
distillation system. This is a membrane permeation process that
separates pure water from a less pure solution containing dissolved
chemicals. Rainwater purifying techniques also involves passing
through a pipe surrounded by an ultraviolet light, which kills most
pathogens. Based on the Texas Water Development Board's "Texas Guide
to Rainwater Harvesting", a scientist named Krishna developed a
rainwater harvesting system in 1998 and received approval from the
city of Portland, Oregon, to use his system for all household use (http://www.rdrop.com/users/krishna/rainwatr.htm).
The rainwater harvesting system costs less than $1,500 and consists
of the following components: a 1500 gallon plastic cistern, a 1/2
horsepower shallow-well pump, plastic (outdoor PVC and indoor CPVC)
piping, two particulate filters in series, rated at 20 and 5 micron
particle sizes, an ultraviolet light sterilizer, screen covering the
cistern, a 20 gallon water butyl rubber diaphragm pressure storage
tank, and a reduced pressure backflow prevention device. The cost to
install a similar system in Bangladesh will be much less, because
indigenous equipment will be cheaper than buying from the United
States.
Rainwater harvesting is in use in many parts of the world. There is
a long established tradition of rainwater collection in some parts
of Alaska and Hawaii. City of Austin, Texas, offers rebate for using
rainwater for some household uses. According to the "Sourcebook
Harvested Rainwater", in some areas of the Caribbean, new houses are
required to have rainwater capture systems. Hawaii apparently is
currently developing (or has already developed) guidelines. The
island of Gibraltar has one of the largest rainwater collection
systems in existence. Rainwater offers advantages in water quality
for both irrigation and domestic use. Rainwater is naturally soft
(unlike well water), contains almost no dissolved minerals or salts,
is free of chemical treatment, and is a relatively reliable source
of water for households. Rainwater collected and used on site can
supplement or replace other sources of household water. Rainwater
can be used as drinking water if proper treatment is done before
using. McElveen, a physician from Texas, also developed methods to
treat rainwater for drinking purposes. For drinking water treatment
(http://twri.tamu.edu/twripubs/WtrSavrs/v3n2/article-1.html),
McElveen relies on 5-micron and 1-micron cartridge filters and an
ultraviolet (UV) treatment. He runs an Environmental Protection
Agency test every 8 months for the same contaminants as municipal
utilities test for: heavy metals, volatile organic compounds, pH,
and hardness.
Bangladesh is faced with numerous water-related
problems: flooding, droughts, arsenic contamination of groundwater,
surface water pollution by point sources and non-point-sources of
pollution. To solve these problems, Bangladesh will have to develop
an integrated water resources development plan. Although rainwater
harvesting will not be able to replace all other sources of drinking
water, it will certainly be able to ease the pressure on surface
water and contaminated groundwater usage as the primary source of
drinking water. The development of a rainwater harvesting plan that
is economically and technically feasible for the majority of the
people in Bangladesh should be given high consideration as a part of
the integrated water resources management plan.


